Home | Respect Musical | Radio Interviews | Books & Articles
Respect CD & Book |
Keynote Presentations | Dr. Dorothy Blogs | Contact Info

Assessing the Balance of Your Organization
Questions for Examining the Five Dimensions of Work

How do people go about creating balance in their organizations? The first step is to observe the company and try to see clearly where it stands in regard to the five dimensions -- to take the organization’s temperature, so to speak.

The following table lists some questions that people can ask themselves to assess their organization. The questions in the table relate to the symptoms of disequilibrium, such as regular financial crises, high turnover rates, an air of cynicism, backbiting, problems meeting deadlines, and so on. Indications that problems exist are almost always evident, if only we are willing to see them and accept the message being given to us. Similarly, in our personal lives we usually have evidence when our lives are out of balance. For me, imbalance shows up as forgotten appointments, being sharp with my children or colleagues, and daydreaming of long rest periods. For a manager, the symptoms that indicate personal lack of balance might be an increase in interpersonal conflicts at work and at home, working longer hours with less productivity, and habitually canceling personal appointments or time with family.

The unstarred questions assess positive elements of the organization and the starred questions assess negative elements. When you have completed the questionairre, click on “Tabulate Questionnaire Results” so your scores may be calculated. You will then be taken to a page which shows your percentage scores for each category. You may find, for example, that materially your company does well 85 percent of the time, but emotionally it is only 40 percent effective. Please remember that this is not a scientific measurement but merely gives a general idea of how your organization is doing.


Balance Instrument:

Questions for Examining the Five Dimensions of Work

adapted from Managing with the Wisdom of Love:
Uncovering Virtue in People and Organizations

by Dorothy Marcic, Jossey-Bass Publishers
Yes No
Material
1. Does your company operate mostly in the black?
* 2. Are you in continuous financial crisis?
3. Do you have resources to pay employees decently? (Not whether you actually do, merely if you could.)
* 4. Are compensation differentials between top and bottom excessively large? Increasing?
* 5. Do you have high turnover rate for employees?
6. Are the places of work (factories, offices) clean, comfortable, well kept and adequately furnished?
7. Is equipment used modern (enough), efficient, and safe?
8. Do you have a decent, updated building and offices?
9. Are supplies good quality?
*10. Are there frequent shortages of equipment and supplies, because new ones are not purchased often enough?

Intellectual
1. Do your engineers, technicians, or others keep up with cutting edge technology?
2. Do you spend adequate resources to send people for continuing education or important professional conferences?
3. Is spending on continuing education increasing as percent of sales?
4. Are employees able to get reference materials, books, journals, and magazines, which will help them learn more about their work and the environment?
5. Do you reward employees who continue to learn?
6. Are people happy to learn (rather than having to coerce them)?
7. Do other organizations respect the knowledge of your employees?
8. Do you respect the knowledge of your employees?
* 9. Do employees often lack the necessary competence to complete projects adequately and on time?
10. Do employees get enthused about one another’s ideas?

Emotional
1. Does there seem to be high levels of job satisfaction?
2. Do people enjoy working with each other?
3. Do employees like one another?
* 4. Are there disproportionately high problems with depression, alcoholism, frequent, even violent, outbursts?
* 5. In meetings do people behave defensively, and with power plays?
* 6. Are people afraid to bring up what they really feel in meetings?
* 7. Is there frequent concern about "not upsetting the boss"?
8. Do employees frequently get together outside of work?
* 9. Is there a lot of "sucking up" to bosses?
10. Do employees feel appreciated?

Volitional
1. Is there a willingness to look at new ways of doing things?
2. Do you rarely hear "It won’t work" or "That’s impossible to do"?
3. Is there a high level of energy on new projects?
* 4. Do workers put energy into maintaining the status quo?
* 5. Are new programs met with many complaints and much resistance?
6. Do people enjoy "bouncing around" innovative ideas?
* 7. Do employees wait for the boss to come up with a new idea?
* 8. If someone comes up with a proposal for an innovative project, does everyone else wait and see what the boss’s reaction will be before they react?
9. Do workers sometimes come in excited about something they heard about and try to get others to see how it might be applied here?
*10. Are new idea generators met with disdain?

Spiritual
1. Is there an acceptance and assumption of integrity amongst co-workers and bosses?
2. Do people trust one another? Do they trust management?
* 3. Do employees feel exploited or treated unjustly?
4. Do customers expect and get a quality product?
* 5. Is cynicism common amongst employees?
6. Do people joyfully help one another?
* 7. Is there a lot of backbiting?
* 8. Are there political fights? Political intrigues? Political posturing?
9. Is there an openness of communication that depends on a deep level of trust and commitment?
*10. Do people say different things to different people?
11. Is there a unity of "theory" and "practice" (i.e., managers practice what they preach)?
12. Can groups discuss problems and handle conflict in a competent and dignified manner?
13. Is there a "spirit" of service to each other, to clients, suppliers?

Note: * indicates negative scoring.



Please tell us a bit about yourself.

First Name:
Last Name:
Company:
E-mail Address:

* Personal information you are submitting will not be shared with others.

Type of work you do:
Type of organization you work in:
Size of organization:
Levels between you and the CEO:

     


All material copyright © 1998-2002, by Dorothy Marcic
Last update: July 2002